| 31 Aug 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | New York City FC | — | → |
| 28 Aug 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Philadelphia Union | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 24 Aug 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Philadelphia Union | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 20 Jul 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Atlanta United FC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 17 Jul 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Charlotte FC | — | → |
| 14 Jul 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Los Angeles FC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 06 Jul 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Toronto FC | — | → |
| 03 Jul 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Nashville SC | — | → |
| 29 Jun 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | New England Revolution | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 22 Jun 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Sporting Kansas City | — | → |
| 19 Jun 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Inter Miami CF | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 14 Jun 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | New York City FC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 25 May 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Orlando City SC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 19 May 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Chicago Fire | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 15 May 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Montreal Impact | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 11 May 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | FC Cincinnati | — | → |
| 27 Apr 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Montreal Impact | — | → |
| 20 Apr 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Portland Timbers | — | → |
| 14 Apr 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Real Salt Lake | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 06 Apr 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | D.C. United | — | → |
| 31 Mar 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Nashville SC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 23 Mar 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Charlotte FC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 16 Mar 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | New York Red Bulls | — | → |
| 10 Mar 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Chicago Fire | — | → |
| 02 Mar 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Minnesota United FC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 24 Feb 2024 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Atlanta United FC | — | → |
| 09 Dec 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Los Angeles FC | — | → |
| 02 Dec 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | FC Cincinnati | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 25 Nov 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Orlando City SC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 13 Nov 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Atlanta United FC | — | → |
| 08 Nov 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Atlanta United FC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 01 Nov 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Atlanta United FC | — | → |
| 21 Oct 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Montreal Impact | — | → |
| 07 Oct 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Atlanta United FC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 04 Oct 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | New England Revolution | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 30 Sept 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Philadelphia Union | — | → |
| 24 Sept 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | FC Dallas | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 20 Sept 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Chicago Fire | — | → |
| 16 Sept 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Orlando City SC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 02 Sept 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Montreal Impact | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 31 Aug 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Houston Dynamo | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 26 Aug 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Toronto FC | — | → |
| 20 Aug 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | FC Cincinnati | — | → |
| 16 Jul 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Portland Timbers | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 08 Jul 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | New York City FC | — | → |
| 04 Jul 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Inter Miami CF | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 01 Jul 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | New York Red Bulls | — | → |
| 24 Jun 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Columbus Crew SC | - : - | Nashville SC | — | → |
| 17 Jun 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | New York City FC | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |
| 11 Jun 2023 | Major League Soccer (USA) | Chicago Fire | - : - | Columbus Crew SC | — | → |